Prayers for Healing—Do They Work?

Clinical trials versus biblical perspective

John Shin

A close-up of a person gently holding the hand of someone lying in a hospital bed.

“Those statistics don’t matter to me, Doc. Let’s just get started with treatment!” I was trying to explain to my patient the likelihood that his chemotherapy regimen would be successful. His response caught me off guard. He had bladder cancer, and although it was still potentially curable, it was locally advanced, which meant it carried a significant risk of recurrence. In such situations as this patients often express anxiety about the possibility that treatment may not work, but this patient was different. He seemed confident that he would have a good outcome.

As I reviewed the potential toxicities of his regimen, he smiled and said, “I’m sure I’m going to do just fine. I have 10 different churches praying for me—literally thousands of people—so I have no doubt in my mind that everything is going to go well.” Remarkably, he went on to do extremely well with chemotherapy. He tolerated treatment with minimal side effects, and his bladder tumor shrank dramatically. After surgery he was cancer-free. Afterward I told him we should praise God for his wonderful outcome. He winked at me and said, “That’s the power of prayer, Doc!”

Although I was very happy for my patient, it made me wonder about the role of prayer in healing. Did the prayers of 10 congregations truly increase his chances of responding to treatment? If so, is prayer a numbers game such that we should try to “crowdsource” prayers for the best result? I thought of my father, who died of brain cancer in 2008. We did not have thousands praying for him, but we certainly had hundreds. Was that not enough? Should we have enlisted the aid of more congregations? And most important, if God is truly loving, why would the fervent prayers of a single individual not be enough? I knew the answer had to be more complex, because I had seen patients do well when only they and their spouse were praying. I had also seen patients succumb to their disease despite having people around the world praying for them. And then there were those patients who did not pray at all and yet were cured. So what difference does prayer really make?

Clinical Trials on Prayer

Scientists have attempted to answer this question through clinical trials. In 1988 cardiologist Randolph Byrd published a landmark study involving patients admitted to a coronary care unit. He randomly assigned 192 patients to receive Christian intercessory prayer and 201 patients to receive usual care without organized prayer. The prayer group had fewer episodes of congestive heart failure, required less diuretic use, and had lower rates of cardiopulmonary arrest, pneumonia, antibiotic use, and intubation or mechanical ventilation.1

A second study, published in 1999 by William Harris and colleagues, randomized 990 coronary care unit patients to receive remote intercessory prayer or usual care. The first names of patients in the prayer group were given to outside intercessors who prayed for them daily for four weeks. The patients did not know they were being prayed for, and the intercessors never met them. Outcomes were measured using a “CCU course score,” with lower scores indicating a better hospital course. The investigators found that patients in the prayer group had lower CCU course scores than those in the usual care group.2

There is nothing wrong with asking God for healing . . . yet, like Jesus in Gethsemane, our prayers should ultimately yield to the will of God.

Although these studies appeared to suggest a therapeutic benefit from intercessory prayer, both have been widely criticized for limitations in study design and lack of reproducibility. A comprehensive Cochrane Review, first published in 2000 and updated in 2007 and 2009, evaluated 10 studies involving 7,646 patients and found no clear effect of intercessory prayer on mortality, overall clinical status, coronary care unit readmission, or rehospitalization. The authors concluded that the available evidence was not for or against recommending intercessory prayer, and questioned whether additional efficacy trials would be the best use of research resources.3

The most influential negative trial was the STEP (Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer) study, which enrolled 1,802 patients who underwent cardiac bypass surgery. Complication rates were 52 percent among patients who received prayer but were uncertain whether they were being prayed for, 51 percent among those who did not receive prayer and were uncertain of their assignment, and 59 percent among those who knew they were receiving prayer. Major events and 30-day mortality were similar across all three groups.4 This trial should not be interpreted as evidence that prayer is harmful. It did, however, argue against a clinically meaningful benefit from blinded distant intercessory prayer in this setting while also raising the possibility that expectancy effects or performance anxiety may worsen some outcomes when patients are explicitly told they are being prayed for.

Prayer Works . . . Differently

Despite the fact that the scientific literature has not demonstrated a clear therapeutic benefit from intercessory prayer, there is more compelling evidence that personal prayer is beneficial for coping with illness and for increasing a sense of meaning and hope. A meta-analysis of 49 studies found that positive religious coping—often with prayer as a central component—was associated with better psychological adjustment to stress, as well as greater life satisfaction and happiness.5 Similarly, a study of hospitalized veterans reported an inverse association between religious coping and depressive symptoms,6 and studies in cancer and serious illness have frequently found that prayer-related variables are associated with better coping and quality of life.7

Some may look at this data and conclude that while prayer may help people feel better as a coping mechanism, it does not actually affect healing. Is that the right conclusion? Einstein once said, “It would be possible to describe absolutely everything scientifically, but it would make no sense. It would be without meaning, as if you described a Beethoven symphony as a variation of wave pressure."

Perhaps the reason that studies on prayer have not been more definitive is that clinical trials—and even the scientific method itself—are not the right tools to capture the full impact and purpose of prayer. Suppose, for example, that a patient came to accept Christ as a result of intercessory prayer but still died from their illness or experienced the same complication rate as the average hospitalized patient. From a clinical trial standpoint, that patient would be counted as having received no measurable benefit.

Prayer is not like medication, where a predictable, reproducible outcome can be expected whenever it is applied. Jesus immediately healed the bleeding woman when she reached out in faith, but He did not remove Paul’s thorn in the flesh despite Paul’s repeated prayers. If God always answered our prayers for healing exactly as we expected, we would treat Him like a vending machine in the sky: insert the required quantity of prayers and receive the desired outcome. But in God’s loving providence, we know that not every prayer for healing is answered on this side of eternity, and we trust that if we knew the end from the beginning, we would have it no other way.

The Purpose of Prayer

Although we cannot presume how God will answer our prayers, the Bible consistently encourages both personal and intercessory prayers for healing. In Psalm 30:2 David testifies, “O Lord my God, I cried out to You, and You healed me.” Likewise, James 5:14-16 instructs believers, “Is anyone among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him. . . . Pray for one another, that you may be healed. The effective, fervent prayer of a righteous man avails much.” In 2 Kings 20 Hezekiah prays earnestly for healing, and his life is extended by 15 years. Why, then, are we encouraged to pray for ourselves and for others when healing cannot be assumed?

To answer this question, we must necessarily consider the true purpose of prayer. If it is to persuade God to give us what we desire, then its aim would be to inundate Him with enough petitions until He finally grants our request. This is not so. Ellen White writes, “Prayer is the opening of the heart to God as to a friend. Not that it is necessary in order to make known to God what we are, but in order to enable us to receive Him. Prayer does not bring God down to us, but brings us up to Him.”8 She also states: “Prayer is not to work any change in God; it is to bring us into harmony with God.”9The purpose of prayer, then, is not to change God, but to change us. At its heart, prayer is the means by which we enter into a deeper relationship with God, allowing Him to shape us more fully into His likeness and to awaken within our hearts a genuine love for Him.

We surrender our will to Him, not because our desires are unimportant, but because we understand that His wisdom is greater than our understanding, and trust that His purposes are ultimately better than anything we could choose for ourselves.

Prayer allows us to give voice to the cries of our hearts, and also provides an opportunity to align our will with God’s, even when it runs contrary to our own desires. Jesus modeled this in Gethsemane. Bearing the weight of the world’s sins and facing separation from God, He did not want to undergo the trial set before Him. Thus in Matthew 26:39 He prayed, “O My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from Me; nevertheless, not as I will, but as You will.” Jesus was honest about His anguish and did not hesitate to bring His petition before the Father. In fact, He prayed the same prayer three times. He truly desired, if possible, for the cup to pass from Him. Yet in the end He submitted His will to the Father’s will, even when that submission led Him toward the cross. 

Faith and Surrender

Jesus’ example should serve as the pattern for our own prayers. God invites us to be honest with Him. When we or someone we love becomes ill, the desire for healing is both natural and deeply human. There is nothing wrong with asking God for healing, and Scripture encourages us to do so. Yet, like Jesus in Gethsemane, our prayers should ultimately yield to the will of God. This is the faith component of prayer: not merely asking God to grant our desires, but allowing Him to bring our desires into harmony with His purpose, acknowledging that we do not always see the larger picture. Even when circumstances do not make sense, when the outcome is painful or disappointing, we choose to trust that God loves us and knows what is best.

Praying for God’s will prevents us from making our faith contingent upon outcomes. It moves us away from a “vending machine” theology of prayer, in which God is valued primarily for what He gives, and toward a deeper trust in God Himself. Ellen White expresses this principle in her counsel on prayer for the sick: “There are cases where God works decidedly by His divine power in the restoration of health. But not all the sick are healed. Many are laid away to sleep in Jesus. . . . We all desire immediate and direct answers to our prayers, and are tempted to become discouraged when the answer is delayed or comes in an unlooked-for form. But God is too wise and good to answer our prayers always at just the time and in just the manner we desire. He will do more and better for us than to accomplish all our wishes. And because we can trust His wisdom and love, we should not ask Him to concede to our will, but should seek to enter into and accomplish His purpose.”10

We trust God, then, not because He does good things for us or grants our requests, but because we know that He loves us. We surrender our will to Him, not because our desires are unimportant, but because we understand that His wisdom is greater than our understanding and trust that His purposes are ultimately better than anything we could choose for ourselves.

Almost a year after his surgery, my bladder cancer patient underwent a routine chest CT scan, and it revealed suspicious-appearing nodules in his lungs. We biopsied one of them, and unfortunately, it confirmed metastatic bladder cancer. His disease had not only returned but was now incurable. He and his wife were devastated. My patient had been so certain that God had answered his prayers for healing and had completely cured him. Why had God allowed him to believe he was healed, only for the cancer to return? Was God toying with his emotions? He was deeply disappointed and confused. I did my best to console him, but it was clear that he was experiencing a crisis of faith that words alone could not resolve. As he left my office that day, I prayed that God would comfort him and speak to his heart in a way that only He could.

I saw my patient again about a month later as we prepared to begin chemotherapy, but this time there was a remarkable change in him. He seemed at peace and even eager to start treatment. I told him that he appeared to be in a better place. He explained that after hearing the news of his metastatic cancer, he had become angry with God and had fallen into a period of depression. Yet in the days that followed, things began to happen that convinced him God was still with him. His supervisor granted him as much paid time off as he needed, ensuring he could pay his bills. His friends volunteered to provide meals and transportation during the months ahead as he underwent treatment. A neighbor came over and repaired his broken air-conditioning unit without being asked. Although his cancer had returned, he could not deny that God was taking care of him. “Doc,” he said, “I don’t know why God let this cancer come back. But I know He’s still up there, and I know that He loves me.” He smiled as tears filled his eyes. “And that’s enough for me."


  1. 1

    R. C. Byrd, “Positive Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer in a Coronary Care Unit Population,” Southern Medical Journal 81 (1988): 826-829.

    Back to reference 1
  2. 2

    W. S. Harris et al., “A Randomized, Controlled Trial of the Effects of Remote, Intercessory Prayer on Outcomes in Patients Admitted to the Coronary Care Unit,” Archives of Internal Medicine 159 (1999): 2273-2278.

    Back to reference 2
  3. 3

    L. Roberts, I. Ahmed, S. Hall, and A. Davison, “Intercessory Prayer for the Alleviation of Ill Health,” Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2014, CD000368 (2009).

    Back to reference 3
  4. 4

    H. Benson et al., “Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP) in Cardiac Bypass Patients: A Multicenter Randomized Trial of Uncertainty and Certainty of Receiving Intercessory Prayer,” American Heart Journal 151 (2006): 934-942.

    Back to reference 4
  5. 5

    G. G. Ano and E. B. Vasconcelles, “Religious Coping and Psychological Adjustment to Stress: A Meta‐Analysis,” Journal of Clinical Psychology 61 (2005): 461-480.

    Back to reference 5
  6. 6

    H. G. Koenig et al.,“Religious Coping and Depression Among Elderly, Hospitalized Medically Ill Men,” American Journal of Psychiatry 149 (1992): 1693-1700.

    Back to reference 6
  7. 7

    M. Vallurupalli et al., “The Role of Spirituality and Religious Coping in the Quality of Life of Patients With Advanced Cancer Receiving Palliative Radiation Therapy,” Journal of Supportive Oncology 10 (2012): 81-87.

    Back to reference 7
  8. 8

    Ellen G. White, Steps to Christ (Mountain View, Calif.: Pacific Press Pub. Assn., 1956), p. 93.

    Back to reference 8
  9. 9

    Ellen G. White, Christ’s Object Lessons (Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald Pub. Assn., 1900, 1941), p. 143.

    Back to reference 9
  10. 10

    Ellen G. White, The Ministry of Healing (Mountain View, Calif.: Pacific Press Pub. Assn., 1905), p. 230.

    Back to reference 10
Comment

About the Author

John Shin is a medical oncologist at Loma Linda University and president of the Adventist Medical Evangelism Network (AMEN), with advanced training from Loma Linda, the Mayo Clinic, and the National Cancer Institute. His research focuses on immunotherapy and lifestyle interventions in cancer treatment.

Sign up for the newsletter

Get the latest Adventist news straight into your inbox.

Related

Featured article image
Wellbeing

Honey, maple syrup, agave . . . healthier than sugar? Not exactly. Learn the sweet truth about natural sweeteners and how to enjoy them wisely.

November 19, 2026

Featured article image
Regional News

A recent conference sought to create more awareness about disabilities, and discussed what local Adventist congregations can do to welcome more people.

November 19, 2026

Featured article image
Regional News

The story of four Seventh-day Adventist women who cycled across Australia for suicide prevention is reaching new audiences worldwide on the big screen.

November 18, 2026

Featured article image
Wellbeing

The people who shaped you also shaped how you view God. But that doesn’t have to be the end of your story.

November 15, 2026

Comments

Leave a comment

We'll send a link to confirm it's you. New here? Your account is created when you confirm. Your address is never published.

Advertisement

Ouchita Hills College