November 19, 2026
The Sweet Truth
Are “natural” sweeteners really healthier than sugar?
Zeno Charles-Marcel

Question: I try to eat a healthy, mostly plant-based diet, and I’ve been cutting back on refined white sugar. But recipes and health products keep using honey, maple syrup, agave nectar, coconut sugar, date syrup, or monk fruit sweetener instead, often described as “natural,” “unrefined,” or simply healthier. I’m not sure whether that distinction really matters, or whether I should just resign myself to bland food.
Answer: This is a good question because food marketing loves to gather very different products under one comforting label: “healthy sweeteners.” Let’s be honest with each other about what’s actually on the shelf. Honey, maple syrup, agave, coconut sugar, and date syrup aren’t chemically identical, but they’re all concentrated, calorie-containing sweeteners—no matter how earthy or ancient the packaging makes them sound. Monk fruit is the one exception here, since its sweetness comes from something other than sugar itself.
But take heart—you are not stuck. None of us are born condemned to a particular sweet tooth. We come into the world liking sweetness; that much is a gift, not a flaw. What changes, over a lifetime, is how much sweetness we’ve come to expect before we feel satisfied—and that expectation was shaped by exposure, habit, season of life, and yes, genetics, too. Which means it can be reshaped. Your palate is not your destiny.
And here’s why this matters beyond your own table: The sweetness you’re wrestling with quietly is the same sweetness reshaping whole populations right now—the growth in sugar-laden diets is no longer a distant “Western” problem; it’s landing hardest in Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Marketing knows no limits. So when you make a quieter choice about what goes on your plate, you’re not just managing your own health—you’re practicing, in miniature, the same discernment the whole world needs to relearn.
The word “natural” tells us where something came from—not how much we should eat, or whether it is metabolically harmless. Nature produces plenty of substances that cause trouble when concentrated or overused. Also, we don’t need to demonize sugar, and we don’t need to crown natural sweeteners with a health halo. Wisdom simply asks us to see food clearly, receive it with gratitude, and use it with temperance.
Your palate is not your destiny.
What Are We Actually Eating?
Most caloric sweeteners combine three familiar sugars: glucose, which enters the bloodstream directly; fructose, processed mainly by the liver; and sucrose, ordinary table sugar, one glucose molecule bonded to one fructose molecule.
White sugar is almost pure sucrose, as are coconut sugar and maple syrup. Honey is mostly free glucose and fructose; agave runs especially high in fructose; date syrup carries both. These differences shape sweetness, texture, and how fast blood glucose rises—but once digested, the body handles the same basic sugar molecules. For practical purposes, honey and syrups all belong with added sugars, distinct from the sugar still locked inside whole fruits and vegetables.
Do honey and natural syrups offer useful nutrients? In small amounts, honey, maple syrup, coconut sugar, and date syrup each carry modest traces of minerals, antioxidants, or plant compounds. These differences are real but often overstated—to get a meaningful dose from any syrup, you’d need to eat far more sugar than is wise. A varied plant-based diet already supplies abundant fiber, potassium, magnesium, vitamins, and protective compounds from vegetables, fruit, legumes, whole grains, nuts, and seeds. Enjoy these sweeteners for their flavor—not as a stand-in for a supplement. And don’t be wooed by a rustic jar, an organic label, or the word “ancient,” which often suggest a purity the product’s actual composition doesn’t support. Look past the image to the substance.
One footnote on agave’s “low glucose spike” reputation: that smaller immediate rise comes from its unusually high fructose content, and it built agave’s health-food image. But glucose response is only one piece of metabolism—fructose is processed mainly by the liver, and large amounts can promote triglyceride production and liver fat. A lower glucose spike doesn’t make a sweetener unlimited or harmless.
Shared Concerns
Despite their differences, caloric sweeteners share real metabolic concerns when used often or in quantity: added calories without the fullness intact foods provide, a contribution to weight gain, fuel for the oral bacteria that cause dental caries, and, in susceptible people, worsened blood-glucose control, triglycerides, or liver fat.
Amount, frequency, and context matter more than whether a sweetener is white, brown, raw, organic, local, or imported. A little maple syrup on oatmeal is nothing like a bottle of sweetened soda—liquid sugar goes down fast, satisfies little, and has never been shown to be “good.” Yet an occasional dessert differs greatly from sweetened drinks and snacks supplying sugar all day long. This is where temperance becomes practical—not blanket abstinence from anything pleasurable, but the wise, self-controlled use of what is good, and the avoidance of what harms. The goal isn’t fear; it’s freedom to enjoy food without being ruled by it.
Nonetheless, the story doesn’t end with metabolism. Weight, blood sugar, and triglycerides are only the effects we hear about most. A wider body of research traces habitual sugar intake into territory most people never associate with sweeteners at all—inflammation, immune function, mood, skin, and even the gut and brain.
The effects of habitual sugar consumption extend well beyond weight gain and blood sugar. The strongest evidence links diets high in free or added sugars to dental caries. Oral bacteria ferment sugar into acids that gradually dissolve tooth enamel, leading to cavities, tooth pain, infection, and even tooth loss.
Another well-established concern is elevated uric acid and gout. Fructose metabolism increases uric acid production, which can trigger painful gout attacks and may contribute to certain kidney stones.
Sugar-rich diets also tend to crowd out more nourishing foods. When sweets and sugary beverages regularly replace vegetables, fruits, legumes, whole grains, nuts, and seeds, overall diet quality declines. This displacement can lead to nutrient inadequacies, poorer tissue repair, and reduced immune resilience.
Research also links habitual high sugar intake with chronic low-grade inflammation. Frequent glucose surges, oxidative stress, elevated uric acid, and inflammation associated with excess visceral fat may increase the body’s inflammatory burden and potentially worsen inflammatory diseases.
Immune function may also suffer. Sustained high blood sugar and chronic inflammation can alter the activity of neutrophils, macrophages, and lymphocytes, resulting in less-effective infection defense, slower wound healing, and dysregulated inflammatory responses. The evidence is strongest in people with persistent hyperglycemia, such as diabetes, though moderate evidence suggests sugar itself also plays a role.
Oral health extends beyond cavities. Diets high in sugar contribute to periodontal disease by promoting an unhealthy balance of oral bacteria and inflammatory responses in the gums, increasing the risk of bleeding gums, periodontal inflammation, and eventual tooth loss.
The digestive system is affected as well. Diets high in sugar and low in fiber may reduce beneficial gut microbes while weakening the intestinal barrier. This disruption of the gut microbiome can contribute to intestinal inflammation and may impair healthy immune regulation.
Amount, frequency, and context matter more than whether a sweetener is white, brown, raw, organic, local, or imported.
Emerging evidence also suggests a relationship between high sugar intake and mental health. Through inflammation, blood glucose fluctuations, oxidative stress, sleep disruption, and effects on the gut-brain connection, habitual sugar consumption is associated with a greater likelihood of depression and anxiety symptoms. Most of this evidence is observational, and the relationship likely works in both directions.
For people prone to acne, diets with a high glycemic load may worsen breakouts by increasing insulin and IGF-1 signaling, stimulating sebum production, and promoting inflammation within hair follicles.
Finally, researchers are investigating possible links between long-term high sugar intake and cognitive decline. Vascular damage, neuroinflammation, oxidative stress, and impaired insulin signaling within the brain may contribute to poorer memory and increased long-term cognitive risk. Although this evidence is still developing and causation remains uncertain, it adds another reason to view habitual sugar consumption with caution.
None of this is cause for alarm over an occasional treat. The strongest evidence concerns habitual, frequent consumption of free or added sugars—especially sweetened beverages—not the sugar naturally contained within whole fruits, vegetables, and other intact plant foods. It simply broadens the case for temperance already made above: reason enough to let amount, frequency, and context—not the sweetener’s label—guide our choices.
Consider the whole date. Whole dates keep their fiber and structure, which slows eating and aids fullness. Turn dates into syrup, and much of that advantage disappears—the sugar becomes far easier to consume in concentrated form. “Made from fruit” is not the same as eating the fruit itself. The wider principle: wholeness matters, in food and in life. Human well-being isn’t just about isolated nutrients—it includes physical, emotional, social, and spiritual health together.
Monk fruit is a different story. Its sweetness comes mainly from mogrosides rather than ordinary sugar, so pure extract contributes little or no glucose, fructose, sucrose, or calories. But most commercial “monk fruit sweeteners” are blended with erythritol, allulose, dextrose, or another bulking agent, which can add carbohydrate or cause bloating in some people. Read the ingredient list, not just the label. Monk fruit can help reduce added sugar but needn’t become a permanent excuse to keep an extremely sweet diet.
Can I Retrain Myself?
So can I retrain myself? To some degree, yes—though the popular phrase “reset your taste buds” oversimplifies the science. Sweetness perception comes not only from tongue receptors but from repeated exposure, expectation, and brain processing. Regularly eating intensely sweet foods makes that level feel normal, leaving milder foods tasting bland. Reduce sweetness gradually, though, and many people find mildly sweet foods becoming more noticeable and satisfying. There’s no strong evidence that this happens because the tongue grows more receptors; it more likely involves altered signaling and learned expectation. Findings are mixed, so it’s more honest to say that people can learn to appreciate less-sweet foods than to promise a guaranteed reset.
There’s a real spiritual parallel: Appetite is shaped by repeated attention. What we repeatedly choose trains desire—regarding not only food but entertainment, possessions, and habits of thought. This doesn’t make every craving sinful—it means self-control grows through practice, and simple foods can become genuinely satisfying over time.
And the spiritual dimension?
Food is a gift, not a god. It nourishes, delights, connects people, and expresses hospitality—but like any good gift, it can become disordered when it dominates our attention or becomes a tool for judging others. A healthy approach holds several things together: gratitude (receiving food as a gift, not an enemy), stewardship (caring for the body without worshipping it), temperance (enjoying pleasure without being ruled by it), discernment (seeing past marketing and trends), grace (not turning dietary choices into tests of faithfulness), and compassion (remembering that access, culture, illness, income, and family circumstances differ).
Healthful living isn’t meant to earn moral worth or spiritual superiority; it supports clearer thinking, more energy, and a life more available to God and others. Reducing sugar as an act of stewardship, and occasionally enjoying dessert in gratitude and fellowship, aren’t opposing choices. The deeper question is whether our habits support wholeness, freedom, and love.
A Practical Way Forward
If you would like to make some changes in your diet, begin by cutting sweetened beverages first. Replacing soda, sweetened coffee or tea, and energy drinks with water, unsweetened tea, or sparkling water flavored with fruit provides one of the biggest health gains, because sugary drinks deliver large amounts of sugar with very little fullness.
Next, make a habit of reading the ingredient list rather than relying on the front label. Sugar appears under many names—including syrup, nectar, juice concentrate, dextrose, and maltodextrin—and terms such as “natural” or “unrefined” describe where a sweetener came from, not how much is present.
Whenever practical, choose whole fruit before processed sweets. Eating a piece of fruit, or pairing fruit with nuts, preserves the fiber and natural structure that slow eating and increase fullness, advantages that concentrated sweeteners simply cannot provide.
Rather than eliminating sweetness overnight, reduce it gradually. Small reductions in the sugar added to coffee, cereal, or baked goods over several weeks allow taste preferences to adjust naturally, making the change more sustainable than an abrupt switch.
Finally, reserve concentrated sweets for deliberate occasions rather than daily habits. Treat desserts and syrup-covered foods as celebrations instead of routine fare. This shifts sweetness from an everyday expectation to an occasional pleasure, reflecting the heart of biblical temperance.
Above all, don’t assume white sugar must always be swapped for an equally sweet “natural” syrup. Gradually lowering your diet’s overall sweetness will likely serve you better than simply trading one sweetener for another. The goal isn’t finding the perfect sugar—it’s building a pattern in which concentrated sweetness is occasional rather than constant, and food serves life instead of controlling it.
In spiritual terms, the aim isn’t restriction for its own sake, but freedom: freedom to receive with gratitude, choose with wisdom, enjoy with moderation, and care for the body as a trusted gift for service. As Proverbs 25:27 puts it: “It is not good to eat much honey, nor is it glorious to seek one’s own glory” (ESV).
About the Author
Zeno L. Charles-Marcel, a board-certified internist, is the director of Adventist Health Ministries at the General Conference.
Sign up for the newsletter
Get the latest Adventist news straight into your inbox.
Follow us:
Related

A World of Possibilities for Those on the Spectrum
A recent conference sought to create more awareness about disabilities, and discussed what local Adventist congregations can do to welcome more people.
November 19, 2026

They Rode to Support Suicide Prevention. Now They Are on the Big Screen
The story of four Seventh-day Adventist women who cycled across Australia for suicide prevention is reaching new audiences worldwide on the big screen.
November 18, 2026

Dear Heavenly Warden
The people who shaped you also shaped how you view God. But that doesn’t have to be the end of your story.
November 15, 2026

Treatment for Mental Health Among Youth Has Spiked. What Can Be Done?
Youth mental health treatment has surged since the COVID-19 pandemic. An expert from Loma Linda University Health discusses options for treatment and use of medication.
November 15, 2026
